Trying to decide where to stay in Waikiki? We spent ten days in Honolulu and stayed at two very different—but equally memorable—hotels: the Beachcomber Waikiki by Outrigger and the iconic Halekulani Hotel. In this hotel comparison, we break down the pros, cons, and surprises of each to help you choose the right fit for your Oahu vacation.
Beachcomber Waikiki: Budget-Friendly and Beach-Adjacent
We stayed four nights at the Beachcomber Waikiki and found it to be a fantastic option for travelers looking for value and convenience.
What We Loved:
Great location right across from Waikiki Beach
Clean rooms with cheerful, modern decor
Friendly service and a relaxed vibe
The guava bread at Aroma Caffe (yum!)
Please note that some of the links in this post (not all) are affiliate links, and at no additional cost to you, we earn a commission if you make a purchase. We would never recommend anything we don’t personally love.
What to Know:
While not beachfront, it’s just a quick walk to the water. On the way to the water, stop by the Banan Waikiki Beach Shack for a refreshing and delicious dairy-free smoothie or “ice cream” treat.
Pool exists, but it wasn’t a highlight for us. We do not lounge by pools unless our grandchildren compel us to do so.
Ideal for travelers (like us) who plan to be out and about all day.
Our Verdict:
If you’re looking for a clean, quiet, centrally located hotel in Waikiki that doesn’t break the bank, Beachcomber is a solid choice. We’d stay here again without hesitation.
Book your stay at OUTRIGGER Waikiki Beachcomber Hotel or contact me to help plan your perfect Hawaii vacation. My agency, Travel Like You Dream It, specializes in creating unforgettable travel experiences. Start Planning Now.
Halekulani: Iconic Luxury with Thoughtful Touches
After our time at the Beachcomber, we checked into the Halekulani — and instantly noticed the difference. From the ocean views to the refined service, this hotel is an experience.
What Stood Out:
No resort fees (a rare and welcome surprise in Waikiki)
Partial ocean view room with a breathtaking view
Bathroom with all the bells and whistles
Turn-down service with nightly gifts
In-room lighting that responds to you
Delicious dining: House Without a Key, Orchids, and Halekulani Bakery
Small Luxuries That Made a Big Impact:
Pre-stocked ice bucket as part of the turn-down service
Personalized hospitality from check-in to checkout
Coffee cabinet that lights up when opened
Serene pool area and well-equipped fitness space
Our Verdict:
If you’re celebrating a special occasion or want to treat yourself, Halekulani delivers an unforgettable experience. Luxurious and thoughtful in every way. You can check out our full review of the Halekulani at Unforgettable Luxury at Halekulani: Your Waikiki Oasis.
Book your stay at Halekulani Waikiki or contact me to help plan your perfect Hawaii vacation. My agency, Travel Like You Dream It, specializes in creating unforgettable travel experiences. Start Planning Now.
Which Hotel Should You Choose?
Choose Beachcomber Waikiki if you want a stylish, affordable stay close to the beach. Choose Halekulani if you value elegance, quiet luxury, and thoughtful details that elevate every moment.
Get a Glimpse of Both Hotels in Our Video
Things to Do on Oʻahu During Your Stay
Whether you choose the laid-back charm of Beachcomber Waikiki or the timeless luxury of Halekulani, you’ll be perfectly positioned to explore all the magic Oʻahu has to offer. From classic Waikiki adventures to unforgettable island tours, here are a few of our favorite experiences:
North Shore O’ahu Tour: 4 Top Stops You Can’t Miss (blog)
Hiking Diamond Head: Our Experience + Tips for the Trail (blog)
Is Swimming with Turtles in Hawaii Worth It? Our Honest Review! (video)
Should You Add Spending a Day in Chinatown to Your Honolulu Itinerary? (video)
Wipe Out? Nope! How I Finally Nailed Surfing at 47 (video)
For more travel inspiration, be sure to follow us on YouTube, Instagram, Facebook, and Pinterest.